Comparison of Fixation Techniques in Young Patients with Fracture Neck of Femur: Multiple Hip Screws with Fibular Graft or Multiple Hip Screws Alone

Background: Fracture neck of femur occurs infrequently in young patients compared to geriatric age groups. The occurrence in the younger age group is associated with high-energy trauma and more complications. The study was conducted to compare the results of two fixation techniques in management of fracture neck of femur in young age group patients. Methods: A total of 60 patients included in this prospective randomized trial were divided into two groups. Group I includes patients managed by multiple hip screws with fibular graft and group II includes patients managed by multiple hip screws alone. Assessment of fixation was done on basis of Harris Hip score at 6 week and 3 monthly intervals. Results: According to Garden's classification, a total of 40 (66.67%) cases were of type III, out of which 24 patients were in group I and 16 were in group II. The rest 20 (33.33%) patients were of type IV with 6 cases ingroup I and 14 cases in group II. In our study, functional outcome was calculated according to Harris hip score. In Group I we got 21 patients (70%) with excellent result, 7 patients (23.33%) with good result and 2 patients were failure cases. In Group II 17 patients (56.67%) got excellent outcome, 9 patients (30%) good outcome and 4 were failure cases.Conclusion: The study showed that there was no significant difference in any of the procedures and either of the technique could be employed depending on user experience and skills.